In Maine terminology, this is wicked, indeed: A Classic Chocolate Wicked Whoopie.
KAREN HOCHMAN is Editorial Director of THE NIBBLE.
Whoopie Pies For Kids & Grown-Ups
CAPSULE REPORT: Order a big box of Wicked Whoopies and it will probably become a regular ritual in your home. Give a box as a gift—especially to a young person—and it will be remembered for a lifetime. In the hands of Amy Bouchard, the whoopie pie has been elevated to a gourmet snack food—if there is such a thing—and it is addictively good.
About 12 years ago in the city of Gardiner, Maine, Amy Bouchard, a mother of two, was looking at different opportunities to augment the family income. Fortunately, she started to bake whoopie pies from home, and the business blossomed. From ten pies a day made by hand, factory production has resulted in more than four million Wicked Whoopies baked to date. Her home kitchen has been replaced by a 70-pan commercial oven and a 140-quart mixer. Her husband and two children now work in the operation, which has two retail bakeries, a large wholesale business and an e-tail business to consumers nationwide.
First, about the name, “Wicked”: there is nothing bad about these cream-filled snack cakes, except the calories. Explains Amy, “In Maine, when something’s good, we call it ‘good.’ When something’s great, we call it ‘wicked.’”
Second, to the uninitiated: whoopie pies are a New England cousin to Southern moon pies. They are chocolate snack cake “sandwiches” with a filling. Moon pies use marshmallow, whoopie pies use a cream filling. The traditional whoopie pie uses a devil’s food cake and a vanilla cream filling. Wicked Whoopies start with chocolate, and offer 8 other flavors of cake, some of which waiver from the vanilla filling as well.
These 4.5" diameter, 6-ounce cookie sandwiches with their fluffy cream filling are snack food, dessert and overall addiction. Worse, the “Whoop-De-Doo,” a slightly smaller version of the Classic Wicked Whoopie that is completely dipped in rich chocolate, might as well be mainlined. It is irresistible (photo at right).
People who love the filling in Oreos® should know that the generous amount of filling in Wicked Whoopies is a better version of it—lighter and fluffier. Made from vegetable shortening, confectioners’ sugar, corn syrup and vanilla mixed together for an extended period of time, there is so much filling, we often found ourselves scraping some away. We’ll go on the record and say we are not Oreo fans, and not vegetable shortening fans, either. But, the majority of people will love it. (Amy specifically prefers to use vegetable shortening over a butter cream filling—it gives the whoopie pies a non-refrigerated shelf life of 10 days.)
The Whoop-De-Doo is festively packaged, and
makes a perfect party favor. Photo by Melody
We tasted through the gift sampler—the whole thing—and a box of Whoop-De-Doos. All the cakes are very moist, and our favorites are an eclectic lot. In alphabetical order, they are Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter and Raspberry, coincidentally, one from each of the three “flavor groups” below. And of course, the Whoop-De-Doo, which is sold separately, and is in a class by itself, even though we’ve added it to the Classic Flavors section.
Whoopie Pie Flavors
- Chocolate Chip Whoopie Pie, one of our favorites, is like a chocolate chip cookie turned into a cake—with cream filling (photo at right).
- Classic Chocolate Whoopie Pie, the traditional whoopie pie, is, not surprisingly, the best-seller. It’s rich, dark chocolate cake with fluffy cream filling (photo at top of page).
- Mint Chocolate Whoopie Pie looks exactly like the Classic. The difference is that there is some mint flavoring in the cream filling. We’re very big on mint here at THE NIBBLE, and wished for a heavier touch of it in the filling to make up for the fact that there’s no mint in the cake. Those who like only a touch of mint will be happy.
- Whoop-De-Doo Whoopie Pie. Previously mentioned, these were our undoing. We ceased to be able to eat them just one at a time, and the food addict police needed to be called to remove the remainder. While we didn’t have a love-fest reaction to the Classic Chocolate, somehow covering the whole thing in hard chocolate had a magical effect. We should point out, this is the gourmet version of the Hostess Ding-Dong and Drake’s Cakes Ring Ding.
What happens when favorite comfort foods are turned into whoopie pies?
- Maple Whoopie Pie channels a maple-doused pancake into a whoopie pie. Open the package and it smells like a bottle of pure maple syrup, though it looks like two very fat pancakes with a layer of frosting in-between. They’re so moist and syrupy that if tasting them blindfolded without the frosting, one might easily guess “pancake.” Should you eat one for breakfast? Equating it to a cinnamon bun or other sugary “breakfast pastry”: why not!
- Oatmeal Whoopie Pie is different from the rest of the group. Instead of cake, this whoopie is made from two crunchy, cinnamon-flavored oatmeal cookies. Those who love oatmeal cookies may enjoy this variation.
- Peanut Butter Whoopie Pie is a “whoopie!” for anyone who loves the combination of chocolate and peanut butter. We do, and it was one of our favorites. The cream filling is delicious when flavored with peanut butter. In terms of sandwiching it between layers of chocolate cake: what could be better? (Photo below in purchasing section.)
- Pumpkin Whoopie Pie smells of pumpkin and cinnamon. But we felt that this flavor—specifically the cake—was missing an element of sinfulness or richness that should be part of the whoopie pie experience. If you’re going to expend the calories...then plunge!
|Oatmeal Wicked Whoopie
|Pumpkin Wicked Whoopie
Fruit-Flavored Whoopie Pies
The two fruit entries offer polar opposite perspectives on fruit-flavored whoopie pies.
- Raspberry Whoopie Pie is yellow cake with two fillings: the regular cream topped with raspberry jam. The net effect is a tasty jelly donut.
- Strawberry Whoopie Pie is such a bright pink color, it would delight young girls. The strawberry flavor is subtle, like a strawberry mix cake, overpowered by the filling. We remand this flavor to Barbie tea parties.
|Raspberry Wicked Whoopie
|Strawberry Wicked Whoopie
In The Neighborhood?
If you’re in Maine, visit the Wicked Whoopie bake shops in Gardiner (5 Mechanic Street) and Farmingdale (621 Maine Avenue). You may find seasonal flavors not on the e-tail menu, plus other baked delights.
Wicked Whoopie Pie Gifts
It’s well worth it to get an assorted box. We got every flavor and cut the pies into quarters: one quarter of each flavor was more than enough to get the full whoopie experience and decide what our favorites were.
Even though they’re a snack cake, the experience is so festive that we would serve them at a party (especially a kids’ event or family occasion party) instead of a cake. Or, there’s a “Whoopie Cake,” a five-pound jumbo Classic Wicked Whoopie, which serves 7 to 10 people.
Send a box of Wicked Whoopies to a child, teen or college student, and you will be his or her “favorite person” for eternity—or the equivalent in kid years. Send a box to an adult with a snack food fixation, and the result will probably be the same. Anyone with an artistic eye will appreciate the beautiful floral cellophane and fabric ribbon that package the gift box. The Whoop-De-Doos are in festive violet and chartreuse-striped bags pretty enough for party favors without any additional wrapping—although Wicked Whoopies will custom-print and add special hang-tags to commemorate the event.
Whoopie Pies In:
Chocolate Chip, Classic Chocolate, Jumbo Wicked Whoopie Maple, Mint, Oatmeal Cream, Peanut Butter, Pumpkin, Raspberry & Cream, Strawberry, Whoop-De-Doo
- One Dozen, Any Flavor
- One Dozen, Two Flavors
- One Dozen, Three Flavors
- Party Favors
12 Whoopies with custom-
- Jumbo Wicked Whoopie
Serves 7 to 10
Prices and flavor availability are verified at publication but are subject to change.
Purchase online at
Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET
Additional flavors are available at many retail stores throughout New England.
One of our favorite flavors, Peanut Butter Wicked Whoopie.
Our whoopie fantasy, a platter of Whoop-De-Doos.